Your essay must be five paragraphs. The thesis must be at the end of the introduction paragraph. It must be one sentence long, and you must list the exact literary devices the author uses that you will argue about. Each paragraph should be 3-5 sentences. Do not use first-person pronouns. Stick to the strictly academic. Stick to the familiar, the formulaic, the reasonable, the assured.
Don’t go above and beyond boundaries. Don’t use “I think” or “maybe,” but don’t speak with too much confidence. Don’t acknowledge what you don’t know.
If there’s one thing this class has taught me, it’s that you should know the rules front and back so you know when and how to properly break them. Writing isn’t formulaic. Even the stuffiest academic essay in existence is an act of self-expression.
I learned the formula and followed it well. It got me a 5 on the AP Literature and Composition Exam. But it didn’t teach me confidence in my writing. It didn’t make me a more creative writer. My best writing comes from when I don’t stress too much about staying within the lines, when I let my mind simply put words on the page. This class taught me the importance of voice. Your essays won’t be remembered for their one-page theses, but for their voice, how you communicated ideas.
I’m not saying you should write an essay with no thesis or paragraphs that are ten pages long. The Writing Center consultant in me would ache. But… don’t be too hard on yourself, okay? Write for you. Write what sounds like you. Be creative, explore, try things. Yes, essays should be professional, but if it isn’t you, then what’s the point?